Instant Delivery

Instant Delivery

  • Instant DeliveryGet Free Invoice
  • Customer Support24 X 7 Customer Support
    • Customer Support
      Chat Chat with us now!
      Send Email Send Email!
      Contact Us
Stub Creator
Stub Creator
My Orders
  • Paystub Generator
  • Advanced Paystub
  • Pay Stub Templates
  • Canada Paystub
  • Custom Paystub
  • Tax Forms
    • W-2 Form
    • 1099-MISC Form
    • 1099 NEC Form
    • 1040 Form
    • W3 Form
    • W9 Form
  • Pricing
  • Help
    • FAQ
    • State
    • Paystub App
    • Blog
    • Hourly Paycheck Calculator
    • Glossary
    • Contact Us
Hi
  • My account
  • Manage address
  • Recent Paystub
  • Sign Out

How Should You Respond to Pay Raise Requests?

  1. Home
  2. Blog
  3. How Should You Respond to Pay
Create Stubcreator In Just Few Seconds
How should you respond to pay-raise requests

Posted on:  Mar 9, 2020   By:   Nikul Somani

Using a check stub maker is one aspect of payroll management, while handling pay-raise requests is another. This blog is about helping managers handle pay-raise requests tactfully.

 

According to Karen Dillon, author of HBR Guide to Office Politics:

 

“As a manager, you’re starting with an impressionist painting of how people are paid and whether it’s fair. Also, giving the raise is rarely entirely up to you, and there are a hundred things you have to account for.”

 

By carefully navigating the conversation, a manager can achieve the best possible outcome for both the employee and the company.

 

New User Offer: Get $4.99 OFF on your 1st Paystub Order

 

Make no statements at the moment

 

Instant reactions may drive unexpected results. Expressions like “You deserve this” or “Are you mad or what?!” reflect your initial opinion. Instead of this, stay neutral. Your answer should be something like this: “I will forward your request to the HR Department.” Also, hold your expressions within and make sure that you don’t look angry or irritated with such a request.

 

Acknowledge the Individual’s Courage

 

Change your perception with which you look at the appraisal request. If the employee speaks to your face for a pay raise, he/she is vulnerable because of an underpaid feeling. At the same time, they are giving you the opportunity to retain them rather than making them go out to find another job.

 

Catch the Indirect Signals

 

Some employees may not ask for it directly but give indirect signals like a change in their dressing style and more. Pay attention to such details and ask for follow-up questions if you think the person might be a flight risk. If you think they’re worth it, you should consider a raise.

 

3 Setbacks of not using Pay Stub Generator

 

Know the alternate ways to promote

 

You can make employees feel valued in different ways than always giving a pay raise. They can be offered a one-time bonus in a year, or they can be sent to attend a prestigious conference on behalf of the firm. Other than this, you may provide them with extra time off. These are a few ways to say ‘I value you’ instead of increasing your salary.

 

Deliver ‘Good News’ the right way

 

When giving a pay raise to the right candidate will benefit the company, don’t miss this chance. Share this good news with the employee as it should be done. They should be made to feel that this hike is a collective decision of the authorities based on the performance analysis and other factors.

 

This will ultimately add to their sincerity to perform better because they received what they deserved.

 

Try the free pay stub template to define the paycheck format for your firm

 

Be specific for ‘Bad News’ too

 

Even if the decision is not in favor of the employee, they should be replied to with a humble attitude. You can say that you have evaluated their performance and the pay scale in the market, and you think that they are being paid appropriately.

 

The Takeaway

 

Your attitude can make or break the situation. Handle such critical situations smartly. We hope these tips will help you get through the process smoothly.

 

Would you like to continue with our paystub creator & deliver accurate paychecks to your employees?

 

Related Article: Avoid Payroll Issues with Paystub Generator

 

FAQ's

How should you evaluate a pay raise request from an employee?

+

When evaluating a pay raise request from an employee, it is important to consider factors such as the employee's performance and contributions to the company, the current market rate for similar positions, and the company's budget and financial situation.

How should you communicate your decision regarding a pay raise request to an employee?

+

When communicating a decision regarding a pay raise request to an employee, it is important to be transparent and clear about the reasons for the decision, whether it is a positive or negative outcome. If the request is approved, it is important to provide details about the amount and timing of the increase. If the request is denied, it is important to provide constructive feedback and offer suggestions for improvement.

What are some alternative ways to address an employee's request for a pay raise?

+

In addition to approving or denying a pay raise request, there may be other ways to address an employee's request for increased compensation. This could include offering additional benefits, such as increased vacation time or flexible scheduling, providing opportunities for professional development or career advancement, or offering a one-time bonus or incentive.

Save money with our free pay stub generator!

Never worry about lost or misplaced pay stubs again - keep them all in one place with our tool. Create Free Paystub

Related Blogs

OBBB Act 2026 Explained - A Complete Guide to Payroll Revolution

OBBB Act 2026 Explained: A Complete Guide to Payroll Revolution

Jan 15, 2026

The 2026 Changes in a Nutshell: The 2026 Payroll Revolution is a…

OBBB Act 2026 Explained: A Complete Guide to Payroll Revolution

Pathik Sopariwala Jan 15, 2026

The 2026 Changes in a Nutshell: The 2026 Payroll Revolution is a…

Bi-weekly vs Semi-monthly Pay

Bi-Weekly vs Semi-Monthly Pay: Complete Guide to Pay Frequencies

Jan 9, 2026

What is the difference between bi-weekly and semi-monthly pay? The main difference…

Bi-Weekly vs Semi-Monthly Pay: Complete Guide to Pay Frequencies

Pathik Sopariwala Jan 9, 2026

What is the difference between bi-weekly and semi-monthly pay? The main difference…

Payroll Card vs Direct Deposit

Payroll Card vs Direct Deposit: What’s the Difference & Which Is Better?

Jan 7, 2026

When comparing direct deposit vs payroll card, both are common employee payment…

Payroll Card vs Direct Deposit: What’s the Difference & Which Is Better?

Iliyaskhan Pathan Jan 7, 2026

When comparing direct deposit vs payroll card, both are common employee payment…

Create Free Paystub
Secure Payment Via:
all payment methods
Satisfaction Guarantee
Secure Ordering
Money Back Guarantee
Compliant Layouts
2026 IRS & SSA Compliant Layouts

Updated with the OBBBA

About StubCreator®

StubCreator is an online paystub generator tool to create accurate, detailed pay stubs easily without requiring a payroll system. This tool is specifically designed to meet the unique needs of employees, independent contractors, and any other type of business. It provides accurate calculations of federal and state taxes in all 50 states, allowing users to produce compliant paystubs.

Quick Links

  • Terms & Conditions
  • Privacy Policy
  • Refund Policy
  • Blog
  • Glossary
  • FAQ
  • Paystub App

Paycheck Stubs

  • Paystub Generator
  • Advanced Paystub
  • Canada Paystub
  • Custom Paystub
  • In Progress Paystubs
  • My Paystubs
  • Self Employed Stub
  • Independent contractor

4.8 / 5
Based on 7825 reviews

Follow Us

© 2026 STUBCREATOR.COM, ALL RIGHTS RESERVED

Sign In to Stubcreator

Forgot password? Reset
Don't have an account? Sign Up

Sign Up to Stubcreator

Check your email you can get the passsword, if you have already password then enter password and sign in to stubcreator account.
Already have an account? Sign In